Pulisic: AC Milan turn down New York City and declare him untouchable
A significant piece of news has emerged concerning Christian Pulisic: New York City FC reportedly tabled a substantial offer to secure the services of the American attacking midfielder, putting forward approximately $50 million spread over five years — equating to roughly $10 million per season. A financially attractive proposal by any standard, particularly within the context of MLS. Milan’s answer, however, was unambiguous: no.
The story comes from ESPN, the American sports network with direct contacts in both Pulisic’s camp and the circles close to Gerry Cardinale, Milan’s owner — making this a particularly credible and well-sourced piece of information.
Why Milan are keeping Pulisic: brand, marketing and the US market
The decision to reject New York City’s offer is not purely a sporting one — it is, to a large extent, strategic. Gerry Cardinale, founder of RedBird Capital Partners, has always understood Pulisic’s value not just as a footballer, but as a brand ambassador for AC Milan in the United States. The Hershey, Pennsylvania-born forward is one of the most recognisable faces in American football, the captain of the US national team and an icon for a generation of fans across the Atlantic.
In an era when European clubs are increasingly eyeing the North American market — not just as a talent pool, but as a commercial and sponsorship opportunity — losing Pulisic would mean giving up a major marketing and image asset. Milan are fully aware of this, which is precisely why they regard him as untransferable, regardless of what offers arrive.
The contract renewal puzzle: deal expires in 2027
There is, however, an aspect that adds complexity to the picture: the contract renewal. Christian Pulisic‘s current deal with Milan expires in June 2027, and to date negotiations over an extension have not resulted in a signature. The club is understood to have already tabled an offer, but the player — through his representatives — has sought better financial terms than those currently on the table.
It is worth noting, however, that Milan hold a unilateral option to extend the contract until 2028, a contractual safeguard that gives the club solid protection in the event of a stalemate. This means that, even without a short-term agreement, the Rossoneri retain control of the situation and are not at risk of losing the player on a free transfer in 2027.
Pulisic: a mixed season, but the future is Rossoneri
Strictly from a sporting perspective, Pulisic endured a mixed season with Milan, alternating top-level displays with less convincing outings. Even so, he remains one of the most technically gifted and unpredictable players in the squad — capable of conjuring moments of magic when it matters most. His European experience — accumulated at Chelsea, Borussia Dortmund and now Milan — makes him a player who is difficult to replace.
With the World Cup approaching — and the United States among the host nations — Pulisic will be in the global spotlight over the coming months. A standout tournament in the Stars and Stripes shirt would only increase his market value further, making Milan’s decision to hold on to him all the more justified.
The club’s message is clear: Pulisic is not for sale. And the love story between the American and Milan looks set to continue, much to the disappointment of New York City FC.
